Modi’s Sea-plane Ride Violated Law: Read Dr. EAS Sarma’s Letter to Election Commission

Open letter to the Chief Election Commission by Dr. EAS Sarma, former Union Secretary, Ministry of Power.

To

Shri A K Joti
Chief Election Commissioner
Election Commission of India

Shri P K Sinha
Cabinet Secretary

Shri Rajiv Gauba
Union Home Secretary

Dear S/Shri Joti/ Sinha/ Gauba,

I enclose a Business Standard report dated 14-12-2017 (“Gujarat: Did Modi’s seaplane fly from Karachi to escort him to Dharoi?”) which confirms that…

1. During his travel in Gujarat in connection with BJP’s election campaign, Shri Narendra Modi accepted an AIR RIDE from Ahmedabad to Dharoyi and back on a sea-plane on 12-12-2017. THE SEAPLANE was an aircraft (Kodiak 100) OWNED by a FOREIGN COMPANY, namely, Utah-based Quest Aircraft Company, operated by a Japanese plane-maker. Apparently, the aircraft is also owned by the BANK OF UTAH with registration in the US.

ii. The contents of the news report suggest that the Prime minister’s aerial ride was intended to BYPASS the lack of police permission for a road show in Gujarat. The news report states that “BJP went a little overboard in highlighting Modi’s last rally for Gujarat polls. BJP’s twitter handle posted ‘Modi becomes first passenger of India’s first ever seaplane!’” This leads to the inescapable inference that the sea-plane ride was intended to be a part of the election campaign.

iii. In other words, the expenditure incurred on the sea-plane ride, whether paid for or not, will have to be deemed to be a part of the election expenses for BJP’s Gujarat election campaign, as envisaged in the Representation of the People Act and it therefore needs to be reckoned as such by the Election Commission of India (ECI)

iv. The news report estimates the cost of the sea-plane ride to be Rs 40 lakhs. Since an aircraft owned by a foreign company was involved, this amounts to a outright violation of the FCRA. FCRA prohibits political parties from accepting donations, direct or indirect, from a foreign source.

v. If either the Central govt agencies or the State govt agencies have paid for the expenditure incurred on the sea-plane ride, the ECI should take cognizance of the same and take such action that is appropriate against all those responsible for diverting public funds for private electioneering.

I request the ECI to treat the implicit cost of the sea-plane ride as a part of the election expense of BJP in the ongoing Gujarat election campaign and take necessary action under the Representation of the People Act. This is necessary in order to send a strong message that the ECI would not encourage expensive election campaigning in whatever manner it manifests itself.

Further, I request the Union Home Ministry to proceed against those who have violated the FCRA. Acceptance of donations from foreign sources, in whatever manner they flow in, is unacceptable from the point of view of long-term national security.

If you fail to take the necessary action, I will be constrained to seek judicial intervention under the Representation of the People Act as well as under FCRA.

Regards,

Yours sincerely,

E.A.S.Sarma
14-40-4/1 Gokhale Road
Maharanipeta
Visakhapatnam 530002
Mobile: 919866021646
Email: eassarma@gmail.com
14-12-2017

2 Comments

  1. What Mr Sarma has written makes a lot of sense and clearly Modi is in offense against the ECI.
    But Sarma forgets that Bharat is today operating under the BJP Hindu Rashtra which overrides all usual laws. It is an exceptional regime like Trump’s USA. And the British made laws have in effect lost their force.
    So if Modi under Hindu Rashtra says the seaplane ride is OK, it is OK. Who will challenge the decision?
    Who is to challenge the routine lynching of Muslims? It’s OK under the glorious Hindu Rashtra of the BJP and Bajrang babus.
    [It compares with Trump declaring Jerusalem as Israel’s capital. Who challenges this?]

  2. Violation of law is becoming a consistent feature of the present rulers. As rightly expressed in the letter, the EC should take serious note of the matter and consider remedial measures